Celebrating the bicentenary of the birth of Charles Darwin, we consider his impact on the religious world. The recognition of the process of evolution shook religious traditions with a force whose aftershocks continue to be felt. But this new world view also brought us the possibility of a more connected way of living together and the realisation of the importance and power of change.
Celebrating the bicentenary of the birth of Charles Darwin, let's consider his impact on the religious world. The recognition of the process of evolution shook religious traditions with a force whose aftershocks continue to be felt. But this new world view also brought us the possibility of a more connected way of living together and the realisation of the importance and power of change.
It is interesting to contemplate an entangled bank, clothed with many plants of many kinds, with birds singing on the bushes, with various insects flitting about, and with worms crawling through the damp earth, and to reflect that these elaborately constructed forms, so different from each other, and dependent on each other in so complex a manner, have all been produced by laws acting around us.
These laws, taken in the largest sense, being Growth with Reproduction; inheritance which is almost implied by reproduction; Variability from the indirect and direct action of the external conditions of life, and from use and disuse; a Ratio of Increase so high as to lead to a Struggle for Life, and as a consequence to Natural Selection, entailing Divergence of Character and the Extinction of less-improved forms.
Thus, from the war of nature, from famine and death, the most exalted object which we are capable of conceiving, namely, the production of the higher animals, directly follows. There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.
~Charles Darwin, from The Origin of Species, 1859
Two hundred years ago on the 11th February, Charles Darwin was born. One hundred and fifty years ago, he published “The Origin of Species” – a book that shook the Judaeo-Christian world to its very foundations.
The notion of breaking free from traditional teaching was clearly influential to Darwin. He was nominally an Anglican, but this seems to have been more a matter of convenience than reflective of his beliefs. As an agnostic, Darwin’s theology would have been too radical even for the Unitarians of his time.
It is hard to imagine today the impact of the changes brought about by Darwin and other great thinkers whose work preceded and supported Darwin’s bold proposal. Life, explained Darwin, is as it is not because God made it so, but because of something far more subtle and less dramatic. The force that created the diversity of living things is a process of experimentation. Individuals differ from others or their species in ways that can be passed down to their offspring. Those with advantageous variations in each generation did just a little bit better than others and are slightly more likely to pass these traits on. Over millions of years, tiny changes accumulate to create the strange and wondrous assortment of creatures we see today, including humankind.
Before we knew about evolution, God was the all-powerful creator and designer of life. He created each thing to be suited to its environment or to be useful to His greatest creation – humankind. Human beings stood at the top of the hierarchy of living beings. We were apart from the others and held dominion over them. God was the producer and director and set-designer and held just about every other role in the creation of the universal drama and we – alone among living things were made in his image. The advent of the theory of evolution brought a dramatic change in God’s job description.
With Darwin’s remarkable insight, an understanding of the world that had stood for millennia came crashing down.
It is hard to imagine today what kind of a shock it was for society to recognise the truth of evolution.
You have probably seen the lists that come out every once in a while showing ten most stressful life events we can undergo. They are not cheerful lists, as you might imagine.
At the top is divorce or the death of a life partner.
[What I can’t understand is why the next item on the list is not “shopping at Ikea…” clearly, they are not surveying the right people!]
Next in the list is imprisonment, then death of a family member, major illness or injury, and loss of a job.
It’s easy to understand having each of these items on the list. Every one of them involves real trauma, pain, and loss. Interestingly, almost as stressful as separating from a life partner is reconciling and reuniting with that partner, and the loss of a job is only slightly more stressful than a change of job. We might think that retirement would be the beginning of 24/7 relaxation, but it is also right up there in stress levels.
Each of these life events has in common that it takes our feet out from under us. Our basic assumptions about our lives, the people we share it with, and our sense of purpose in living are challenged. If any of these have happened to you, you will know and recall that lost and empty feeling – maybe a sense of numbness as you try to imagine how to rebuild a life.
In the same way, Darwin’s great realisation pulled the feet out from under western society. God – that ideal companion, the creator of all things, the all-powerful hand that works in our lives, was now was being relegated to t position something like your kindly uncle who you never actually hear from but might visit once a week on Sundays.
The reaction to evolution brought, not surprisingly, a mixture of fear and anger. One Anglican cleric famously claimed that "humanity… would suffer a damage that might brutalise it, and sink the human race".
Some liberal religionists, inclined to accept the truth of the new science, tried to find a place for God in this altered understanding of the world.
Reverend Charles Kingsley called evolution "just as noble a conception of Deity, to believe that [God] created primal forms capable of self development... as to believe that He required a fresh act of intervention to [fill the gaps] which He Himself had made."
One wonders if he truly believed his own words. God was being demoted to the role of setting the great machine of evolution in motion and then stepping back to allow it to operate independently.
It is no wonder that we continue to find those today who want to put the genii of evolution back in its box. Creationism, “creation science,” and now “intelligent design.” It is not sheer obstinacy that leads people to turn to these arguments. They simply want to find a way out of the pain and disorientation of a universe without a constant divine guiding hand.
Whenever old structures crumble, new ones rise to take their place.
Darwin’s innovation brought about a change in world-view that continues to this day. It took from us the comforting notion that there is a divine plan for everything and removed the notion that humankind is the pinnacle of creation, it took away the dominant position we enjoyed, and it took away the changelessness of human nature.
And as it took away, it also gave. Within the understanding that evolution brings, we have the opportunity to understand and appreciate the world in new ways.
First, in a way that the scriptural story never could, evolution guides us toward a deep understanding of connection. You are probably familiar with Mark Twain’s novel “The Prince and the Pauper.” It is the story of a poor boy who happens to look identical to Edward, the Prince of Wales. As fate would have it, they encounter one another and decide to change places.
Nothing could have prepared the two boys for the unfamiliar worlds they would each encounter. The young prince, having lost the power of the throne and his royal birth, encounters the suffering and injustice of the real world. But amid his suffering at the temporary loss of his royal stature, comes connection. He comes to know the common people as real people – rather than as mere subjects to be looked down upon. He grows in compassion and wisdom. He will never again assume the callous, arrogant attitudes of the detached ruler.
The understanding of evolution yanked the undeserved crowns from our heads and the sceptres from our hands. The evolution revolution has not yet fully run its course, but we humans have begun to recognise our kinship with all life. As Darwin himself said, "It is absurd to talk of one animal being higher than another." He recognized that humans are of a kind with other creatures – that evolution does not flow from bottom to top, but from creatures that are poorly suited to their environments to those that fit like a hand in glove.
We increasingly understand that although we may be quantitatively different from other animals, animals we surely are! We carry many of the same needs and instincts as other creatures and we begin to realise that what hurts us also hurts them. We are part of an interconnected web of existence. If we are set apart, it is because we can carry that realisation and act to respect and preserve this great unity.
Second, evolution shows us that we are immersed in an ever-changing universe. In the scriptural view of the world, creation happens once. It’s done. That’s it. Not only is that misleading, is also a tough way to think about our lives. There is always the possibility for growth and adaptation – this is the hopeful truth we can come to see.
Evolution relies on diversity and experimentation. Every slight change in a plant or animal is an experiment. It is a potential improvement even though it is likely to fail. What if you gave yourself complete permission to try even though you might fail? What if failure wasn’t seen as a penalty but a step forward?
Change is a constant and the evolutionary viewpoint helps us to see the beauty and power of that eternal process of transformation.
Today, as we prepare to celebrate our congregation’s new members, the lessons of evolution are very fitting. Within this congregation, we seek unity amid diversity. We know and recognise and rejoice at our differences. They are, as all the tiny variations upon which evolution acts, a source of hope and strength for the future.
And we embrace change. We know that the living being that is a congregation changes with each new arrival. We do not fear this change. We know that each new life brings more life to all and that the flame of love within each new loving heart strengthens the fire in all hearts.
It is our great mission to show the world that diversity can be a strength, that change brings growth toward wholeness, and that we are connected within the single fabric of life.
So may it be with you.